[[!meta title="Panel: Emacs, LLMs, and Free Software"]] [[!meta copyright="Copyright © 2026 Participants"]] [[!inline pages="internal(2026/info/llms-nav)" raw="yes"]] # [Panel] Emacs, LLMs, and Free Software Participants: - Alvaro Ramirez [known by agent-shell.el] - Andrew Hyatt [known by llm.el] - Divya Ranjan [known by canvas patch and Human Emacs] - Karthik Chikmagalur [known by gptel.el] - Kent M Pitman [known as early Emacs contributor, MACLISP, and Common Lisp developer] - Screwlisp [known by lisperGopherClimate show] [[!inline pages="internal(2026/info/llms-before)" raw="yes"]] **Important**: The views expressed by the panelists do not represent official position of FSF and the GNU project. They are no less and no more than individual views of the invited panelists. The topic of AI (as a broad concept) and its flagship technology - LLMs - is rather controversial. Some of us enthusiastically accept the technology and its potential to change lives for the better; some are more cautious, or outright question the long-term consequences for individuals, countries, and the whole world; raise ethical concerns, or point to high energy consumption (especially concentrated in USA). However, there is no doubt that Emacs (and the whole world) cannot ignore the topic. The Emacs community already has both proponents and opponents of the LLMs and a number of LLM integrations have appeared over the last few years. Here, we have brought a number of Emacs users with very different views about AI together, to make the range of positions explicit and to explore how Emacs and its community can support different approaches without fracturing. We tried our best to lay out the questions constructively, and to avoid the general topics that have already been beaten to death in online discussions across the web. We ask both the panel participants and the EmacsConf audience to approach the discussion the same way: with the goal of understanding each other's positions and finding ways for different choices to coexist. Keep in mind that "AI" and "LLM" terms can often mean a number of very different things. For example, LLMs can mean large language model-based text generators, text embedding search models, voice recognition, or even anything related to the field of neural networks or machine learning. There is also often a confusion with people using the word "LLM" referring to the most popular proprietary generative models, although there are also open-weight language models or language models that can run locally. "AI" is also often used interchangeably with "LLM" while it can also refer, say, to symbolic artificial intelligence systems. The questions below will use "AI" as a broad term that covers everything, not just the popular large language models. The "LLM" models will include large language models that can generate text, not limited to the popular SaaSS proprietary models, but also including local LLMs and open-weight models. P.S. There is no system but GNU, and Linux is one of its kernels :) Questions: 1. If you were to imagine an ideal AI software you would use with Emacs, how would it look like? How would it **not** look like? Would it be LLM text generator or entirely different architecture? What freedoms would it need: free/libre source code, open weights and training data if it is an LLM model, or something else? If your answer is that no such software should exist, that is a valid answer. 2. There is a broad range of uses of AI within Emacs. Pick an Emacs-related scenario that you find especially exciting or worrisome and offer us a sense of why that is capturing your attention. 3. LLM-generated text can show up in many places not limited to source code (commit messages, documentation, mailing lists, etc). What do you think about harms or benefits (if any) of LLM-generated text in non-code scenarios? 4. Imagine a partly or fully LLM-generated code submitted to Emacs that implements a long-awaited feature, for example multi-threading support in Emacs or time-zone support in Org. How would you deal with such submission as a maintainer or as a user? What motivates your judgement? You can answer as a maintainer, as a user, or as both. 5. What is one thing the Emacs community should build, document, or support around AI (be it LLM chatbots or other machine learning tech) in the next year? And one thing it should decline to do? **Note that you can ask other questions not limited to the above during public Q&A session after the panel discussion** Related: [[!inline pages="internal(2026/info/llms-after)" raw="yes"]] [[!inline pages="internal(2026/info/llms-nav)" raw="yes"]]